Murder Cleugh
Here in 1610 Robert Lumsden killed Isabella SuddenContext & sources
One of the oldest dated entries in this archive (predating even the disputed Ardwell inscription). Robert Lumsden, a local man with a reputation for pursuing married women and for violence, got a local woman, Isabella Sudden - of lower social standing than him - pregnant with his illegitimate child. On 20 July 1610 he chased her across the hills above Coquetdale and stoned her; she died of her injuries 15 days later, on 4 August. When the King's officers rode from Durham to arrest him, Lumsden reportedly told them 'I care nothing for the King, I care nothing for the Queen and I care nothing for you', grabbed their pistols and swords, and beat them off. He was eventually caught in Newcastle, but the punishment fell well short of the crime: he was made to publicly renounce his sins in the market place at Alnwick, was excommunicated from the Church, and served a month in jail - and was never tried or punished for the killing itself. The marker stone stands in a small stretch of woodland known locally as Murder Cleugh, high above Barrowburn in the Cheviot Hills, near the walking route to Windy Gyle.
- Fabulous North, 'Murder Cleugh in The Cheviots' (fullest account found, sourced in turn from Two Local Explorers)
- Two Local Explorers, 'Cheviots: Murder and Intemperance'
- Chronicle Live, 'Hidden in plain sight - six strange things to look out for in Northumberland' (23 Oct 2022)
- Geograph, 'Memorial Stone, Murder Cleugh' by Michael Graham
Needs an in-person visit
- Northumberland Archives / Durham court records, 1610 - no contemporary court or church record has been traced online for Lumsden's excommunication and imprisonment; all accounts found here are later retellings.
- Town
- Barrowburn, Upper Coquetdale
- County
- Northumberland
- Country
- England
- Coordinates
- 55.4124, -2.2098
- Year
- 1610
- Condition
- Legible
Know something we don't?
Submit a correction, an extra detail, or a photo for this record. Reviewed by hand before it's applied.