Murder Stones.
Garvard, Colonsay, Argyll and Bute, Scotland

Macfie Standing Stone (Carrach Mhic-a-Phì)

Other
Photo of Macfie Standing Stone (Carrach Mhic-a-Phì)
Russel Wills / "Carrach Mhic-A-Phi (Macfie Standing Stone)" / CC BY-SA 2.0
Inscription
Modern commemorative plaque, erected by the Clan Macfie/MacDuffie society, reading approximately: "In 1623 Malcolm, last Chief of our Clan was murdered at this stone by a renegade MacDonald."
Context & sources

BORDERLINE CASE - AN ANCIENT STONE, BUT A GENUINE, WELL-DOCUMENTED KILLING. Flagged via geograph.org.uk. Unlike most other entries logged in this sweep, the murder here is real and well attested: Malcolm MacFie (MacDuffie), the last hereditary chief of Clan Macfie, was captured with several clansmen and killed on Colonsay in 1623 by a party of MacDonalds led by Coll Ciotach ('Colkitto') MacDonald, following a failed uprising led by Sir James Macdonald - after which the clan lost its lands and was dispersed. This is corroborated independently by Wikipedia's 'Clan Macfie' article and multiple clan-society histories (Clan Macfie Australia, ScotClans, Clan MacDubhsith/MacFie societies in Canada), and the clan gathered on Colonsay in 2023 to mark the killing's 400th anniversary. The reason this is logged as a borderline rather than straightforward case: the standing stone itself (Carrach Mhic-a-Phì, an ancient monument) almost certainly predates 1623 by a wide margin, and what marks the connection to the murder today is a modern plaque placed on it by the clan society (reportedly repaired at one point by Ulf MacFie Hagman) - similar in spirit to how this site's existing Muschat's Cairn and Ardwell entries sit at the edge of the 'purpose-built period memorial' genre. Worth including as a real entry, just flagged for that reason.

References Further research needed

Needs an in-person visit

  • Any contemporary 1623 record of Malcolm MacFie's killing (clan/court records of the period) - all sources found here are later clan-history retellings, not contemporary documentation.
Field notes
Town
Garvard, Colonsay
County
Argyll and Bute
Country
Scotland
Coordinates
56.0440, -6.2020
Year
1623 (documented); the standing stone itself is older
Condition
Legible
Contribute

Know something we don't?

Submit a correction, an extra detail, or a photo for this record. Reviewed by hand before it's applied.

Reviewed by hand before publishing — no automated posting.