Llwyd ap Iwan Memorial Stone (Arroyo Pescado / Nant-y-Pysgod)
Lle llofruddiwyd Llwyd ap Iwan. Rhagfyr 29 1909. (Welsh: 'The place where Llwyd ap Iwan was murdered. December 29 1909.') A small, round-topped stone, per the academic source that transcribed it.Context & sources
Found via a Welsh-language search (llofruddiaeth/llofruddio, 'murder'), after Cadw/Coflein/Archwilio themselves turned up nothing - this one came from a Welsh magazine (Barn) article and an academic paper, not a heritage database. Outside the UK/Ireland, but included on the same basis as the Hannington and Jackson Pillar entries - it's an actual inscribed stone marking a murder, this time tied to the Welsh diaspora rather than to Wales itself. Llwyd ap Iwan (b. 20 Feb 1862, Bala; son of Michael D. Jones, founder of the Welsh settlement in Patagonia, Y Wladfa) emigrated to Patagonia in 1886 as an engineer on the Central Chubut Railway, and later explored uncharted parts of the country (1893-97) with Tehuelche guides. By the early 1900s he was managing the Arroyo Pescado (Welsh: Nant-y-Pysgod/Rhyd y Pysgod) branch store of the Compania Mercantil del Chubut, about 30km from Esquel in Cwm Hyfryd. On 29 December 1909 two American bandits, going by the names Wilson and Evans, held up the store; when ap Iwan resisted handing over the safe's contents he was shot dead. A popular legend that the killers were Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid - who had lived at a ranch in nearby Cholila, Chubut, 1901-1907, and were locally well known - persists to this day and inspired academic work (notably theatre scholar Mike Pearson's 'Theatre/Archaeology', 1994, and later 'Carlito's Cave'/'Bubbling Tom' project). Most historians now doubt this: Cassidy and Sundance are generally held to have been killed in a shootout with the Bolivian army in San Vicente in November 1908, over a year before ap Iwan's murder, and Robert Evans and William Wilson - who had lived at Rio Pico, Chubut, and may have known Cassidy and Sundance - are the more commonly cited suspects; they were themselves killed in a military raid about two years after the murder. A contemporary Welsh-language eyewitness account (a letter from Robert Roberts, one of ap Iwan's employees, published in the Welsh press) describes two Englishmen as responsible, adding further confusion to who was actually responsible.
- Michael Pearson, Aberystwyth University research paper transcribing the stone's inscription and giving fullest academic account
- Barn magazine (Welsh), Michael Bayley Hughes, 'Butch, Sundance a'r Wladfa' (Nov 2008)
- Wicipedia Cymraeg, 'Llwyd ap Iwan'
- Fly Fisherman magazine, 'A Wild West Shootout on the Banks of the World's Best Spring Creek' (10 May 2024, English-language account incl. the Evans/Wilson theory)
Behind a paywall
- Mike Pearson, 'Theatre/Archaeology' (with Michael Shanks, Routledge 2001) and related performance work 'Carlito's Cave' - academic book/performance texts discussing the site and the myth-making around it in more depth than the freely-available PDF here.
Needs an in-person visit
- Arroyo Pescado, Chubut Province, Argentina, approx. 30km from Esquel - to photograph/re-transcribe the stone directly and confirm its current condition; coordinates given here are for the general locality (the stream/settlement), not a surveyed position for the stone itself.
- Town
- Esquel, Chubut
- County
- Chubut
- Country
- Argentina
- Coordinates
- -43.031, -70.787
- Year
- 1909
- Condition
- Legible
Know something we don't?
Submit a correction, an extra detail, or a photo for this record. Reviewed by hand before it's applied.