Murder Stones.
Melgarve, Laggan, Highland, Scotland

Clach Chathail

Other
Photo of Clach Chathail
Terry Levinthal / "Clach Chathail standing stones near Melgarve" / CC BY-SA 2.0
Inscription
No inscription - an unweathered granite standing stone, broken in two, about 0.8m high, near Melgarve. Marked on the old One-inch Ordnance Survey as 'Uamh Clach Chathail'.
Context & sources

DOESN'T QUITE FIT - LIKELY AN OLDER MONUMENT WITH A LATER LEGEND ATTACHED. Flagged via geograph.org.uk. Local tradition holds this marks the grave of an Irishman named Cathelus, who eloped with Cluny MacPherson's daughter and was murdered on the spot roughly 250 years before a 2009 written account (i.e. around the mid-18th century) - with the body later exhumed and reburied in consecrated ground, per one named local informant (a Mr MacAskill of Melgarve). But the description of the stone itself - comparatively unweathered granite, and moss/lichen growth suggesting real age - has led to competing theories that it predates the legend considerably: as a territorial boundary marker (it sits near the historic border of Badenoch and Lochaber), or, per one local historian (the late Dr Richardson of Laggan), as a battle-site marker. No contemporary documentation of Cathelus's death was found - this rests entirely on oral tradition recorded in the 1870 Ordnance Survey Name Book and passed down locally.

References Further research needed

Needs an in-person visit

  • Ordnance Survey Name Book, 1870 entry for this stone - the earliest written record of the legend, referenced but not directly read here; likely held by National Records of Scotland or accessible via Scotland's Places.
Field notes
Town
Melgarve, Laggan
County
Highland
Country
Scotland
Coordinates
57.0270, -4.5212
Year
Traditionally c.1750s ("about 250 years ago" as of a 2009 account); stone likely much older
Condition
Fragment only
Contribute

Know something we don't?

Submit a correction, an extra detail, or a photo for this record. Reviewed by hand before it's applied.

Reviewed by hand before publishing — no automated posting.